Frosted Fairytale Bake Shop

Stopping in at the Frosted Fairytale Bakery you’re immediately met with big smiles and great hospitality. I grew up in a family that has made everything from scratch and many of those old recipes have long past away with my relatives over the years but the moment I bit into their key lime pie it brought me right back to when I was 12 again but better. Oh my goodness it was truly heaven. All I can say is thank you Frosted Fairytale Bakery for keeping old traditions alive and being so dedicated to what you do for it is an art and you are most definitely Picasso. Ty

Freshly baked delicious goodies.. Cream puffs, apple cider doughnuts, eclairs, rice pudding, cannolis, bear clubs, danishes, brownies, muffins, mini cheesecakes, macaroons and chocolate covered peanut butter balls and more. We also grabbed Italian wedding soup and a chicken salad croissant sandwich and two generously sized coffees. Amazing small town gem.

The best bakery! Everything tastes amazing, and the place is very welcoming. You are definitely missing out if you haven’t tried them yet!

Great personal service and a wonderful addition to our little village! Also, the baked goods are top notch! ❤

Recently tried this bakery for the first time. I ordered a slice of carrot cake and a cannoli. Both were amazing. Very delicious. I can’t stop thinking about how good they were!! Staff was very nice too. I will be back to get those two things again and try more items. Very glad to have them in our village.