Mathews Insurance, Inc

Mathews Insurance has always been fantastic. They have always been helpful, friendly and efficient.

Expensive and they TRIED to charge us $43 for not filing the proper forms to cancel our homeowners insurance. (Switched companies). My father called them but they have no record of it. Had to fill out some damn form to get rid of the charge. Think they only helped us cuz I was uproariously mad & wanted rid of me.

I don’t know where to start I have so many great things to say about having the team at Mathews Insurance Agency take care of all of my insurance needs. Mallory Swaim is simply the best professional I have ever worked with. She went way above beyond to make sure I am fully covered at the best rate possible. She is very patient and extremely knowledgeable while answering all my questions until I am comfortable with the best plan that meets my needs. She also found opportunities for additional discounts. She sent a follow-up with me when my insurance is due to make sure I didn’t miss a payment. She makes having insurance so easy! I HIGHLY recommend Mathews Insurance Agency for all of your insurance needs.

Let's face it, we all hate paying for insurance! But, the folks at Mathews somehow make taking your money a pleasant experience! On a serious note, if it were not for the customer service that I receive there, I would be shopping for lower rates every day. Mallory Swaim is just an amazing agent. She answers my texts before I send them, morning, noon, night and weekends! She's knowledgeable, patient, and hardworking. Give them a try if you're shopping for insurance!

I lived in Athens for 2 years and used Mathews Insurance the whole time for auto & homeowner’s insurance as well as an umbrella policy. I shopped around and the coverage to value ratio was the best I found. I had questions over the years and loved being able to simply reach out to my agent for answers. The personalized and professional touch is what puts them above the discount online vendors. Thanks to Mallory & her team. The only reason we stopped using them is we moved out of state.