Goodfellas Over-The-Rhine

We were told by a few people to check this place out when we were visiting, and we were not disappointed! As soon as we stepped in the door, the guys downstairs cooking greeted us and told us there was space upstairs to have a drink and order food. The bartenders up there were amazing with their bourbon knowledge and friendliness. The pizza is great. We will definitely be back next time we're in town!

The gentleman behind the counter was amazingly helpful. He was very polite and nice and joked around with us a bit. We got a large pizza and a sun dried tomato bread. They were both absolutely delicious. I couldn't stop eating the bread and it was finished before we got home. The pizza was amazing and fed 4 large adults with plenty for leftovers. I love this place!

The Employees were extremely friendly and even though we arrived just minutes before they closed, they still greeted us with a smile and the gave us more than exceptional customer service. The entire staff was very friendly and I was very happy with the fact that I didn't feel rushed or unwelcomed since they were all just minutes from going home. I am also assuming the young man who waited on us was the manager and because they were about to close up the manager gave us a great deal on our food and the food wasn't old in fact the quality of the pizza was just as good as one that had just come out of the oven. But even though the pizza was average the staff was not. Our experience at Goodfellas was great and I would eat here again and recommend this place to friends and family.

Honestly, this is not good pizza. I would only eat this if I were drunk or had no other options. The fact that so many people give this 5 stars tells me that many people in Cincinnati are just unaware of how tasty of pizza you can have elsewhere in the world, such as NYC or Chicago. I realize that sounds a little snobby, but this pizza gets 2 stars for taste. Maybe I'd give it an extra pity star just because it's convenient.

The perfect place to start and end a great night out, the food is always great quality and the staff is always on top of their game. I've even ran into and sparked conversation with staff from other locations visiting. All around quality people combined with good food and bar service keep me coming back!