Harvey Cedars Pizza Shack & Ice Cream

we ordered a half cheese and half tomato (no toppings) pizza and crab fries. the pie in general had close to no sauce. the crust was like cardboard. the crab fries had just a sprinkle of old bay on them (for $7.50 fries- you’d expect a lot more). the pizza was truly so flavorless and disappointing we had to dip it in the ketchup packets that came with the fries. I haven’t eaten ketchup in years because I find it so gross but this was a moment where I saw it was appropriate. the ketchup had more flavor than the sauce and was the true star of this meal.

The food has gotten so much better. They are fast, good and not extremely expensive.

I love this place I love the atmosphere the food is great the people are nice never had a bad experience there.

Best pizza on the island. Super friendly. Thank you.

The pizza quality is very good, and jumbo-sized slices are awesome.