Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant

My husband and I absolutely loved our much-needed weekend getaway at PSI. The interior is absolutely stunning, with delightful antiques and beautiful common areas for all to enjoy. The rooms are absurdly gorgeous, even the bathrooms. The service from employees was friendly and wonderful, and the rates were a truly good deal, especially considering all that was included.

My husband and I went here for our 10yr anniversary. Reservations were competitive due to Covid (around here restaurant reservations usually isn’t that competitive during the off season). Our waiter was great - attentive without being suffocating and very knowledgeable of the menu. The ambiance was great for an anniversary dinner - with views of the ocean from a window at the front. The food was absolutely delicious - we didn’t have room for dessert even though the dessert menu looking so enticing.

Amy the manager needs to sharpen her people skills. She needs to be more welcoming to her customers. She can be rude. Chris the server was FANTASTIC. Made up for Amy. We love going there every year when we visit Cape May.

The best food I’ve eaten in South Jersey so far! Yes I am I am a chef myself for 22 years, been in the business a little over 30. In the 90s I worked in some of the finest gourmet restaurants Atlantic City had to offer.. Make sure you BYOB! Otherwise, they have a charming selection of locally crafted wines that they sell, not serve…ud83dude09ud83dude09

Amazing food! 5 star restaurant. Wait staff is friendly and professional. Food is delicious, prepared with high quality ingredients. The Inn rooms are comfortable each room offers a special charm.