New York Pizzeria

Moved to Canastota almost two years ago and this has been our favorite pizza in the area. Have ordered multiple times and have never had a problem. Their pizza and wings are fantastic and the quality has been spot on. Delivery drivers are always friendly and usually my order arrives quite quickly.

Service with a smile at every visit! Fantastic lunch special for delicious pizza. Lucky to have a great local place :)

I love the chicken wings but the pricing is ridiculous. So we came yup with a sauce recipe and cook the store bought wings in an air fryer. A fraction of the cost!nnAddendum: To be fair, the pizza and wings at NYP are awesome. Since I've retired, we're forced to cut corners and eating take out is a luxury. We're still stopping for the occasional pizza. I mean no disrespect to the owner. Very nice guy.

After researching top rated eateries, I decided to get my coworkers who live in the area gift certificates to New York Pizzeria. It is a local family owned shop, and I felt it important to support local business. I drove from Syracuse to Canastota to get these gifts. The employees were friendly and it was very difficult not to indulge in the delicious looking slices they had (see pictures!) I will definitely return with my family to eat here.

Best pizza outside of New York City. Blessed to live here with great pizza only minutes away! Wings are always perfect. They make a damn good meatball sub too