John & Mary's Batavia

We ordered through door dash. We are missing a complete fish fry. The girl that answers the phone satiated the cook forgot to put the order up. She said, door dash is a nightmare call directly next time. So, it’s been 39 minutes and no fish fry. I called to ck. On the order and the woman was rude. She immediately tried to blame it on door dash. I explain to her what the nice woman had said about the cook.nI gave her the address and she said the driver will be on his way. I told her I guess I will rethink ordering again and she goes OK fine and hung up on menThis was our first and last time ever ordering from here again

Food is usually pretty good, always nice normal John and Mary’s subs and their souvlaki is amazing. But man their delivery does need some help. We live a little further out (17 min) and it almost always takes 1 1/2-2 hours for two items.

By far the best subs in Batavia! I grew up on john and marys in alden and the Batavia location is exactly all the same food. Would recommend this place over any other pizzeria type place in Batavia. And you cant go wrong with their souvlaki dinners!!! Buy one get one free I think on Tuesday but double check that day first.

Surprisingly great pizza alone with their other menu items that make it a great place to get dinner from. Usually quick service but have at times had a 1 to 2 hour wait but the food was always fresh. Love this place none the less!

We order delivery from there at least once a week. Food is great!