Pizza Paul's

My dad and I have been ordering at Pizza pauls for years they have always been absolutely amazing. The food is always hot when it arrives and the customer service is fantastic.

Been in Upstate for a month . I'd like to consider myself a Foodie with an Opinion. Hands Down all around the best pizza I've had. I will Send my Children. It's Soo FIRE!

Ordered in last night, Calzones were really good, ordered steak sub, dont bother. Saw no cheese, mushrooms or onions. The bun was really fresh. Husband ordered a cold sub, tasteless. Do recommend Paul's balls, they were really good!

Best pizza ever!! Sauce is yummy and the quantity of toppings is just right... consistently. Their double dough pizza is great and is our favorite way of enjoying pizza. We added mushrooms to our pizza the other day and they used fresh mushrooms.nPlease go here, you won't be disappointed.nnWe moved away a couple years ago, but every time we're in the area we make a special trip to Pizza Paul's to take back home with us.

I ordered ahead... I called around 730 pm for an order I wanted to pick up at 850 pm. Upon arrival (on time), they told us our mozzarella sticks were still cooking- which wasn't a big deal so, we sit down and wait. I opened our box of pizza, that we ordered half cheese, half pepperoni, and the pepperoni was clearly only on one side, but had obviously been placed on the pizza haphazardly because there were several random pepperoni on the cheese side. Not for nothing, whoever made the pizza, can clearly see the erroneous pepperoni prior to putting the pizza in the oven, but decided they did not care and cooked it that way anyway. When we received the mozzarella sticks, I tried one after returning to my car and they were overcooked! The item that we were waiting on ended up being overcooked! This was a terrible first experience with Pizza Paul's and we will never order any food from the Geneseo location ever again. They are lazy and take zero pride in their work. I would give zero stars if I could.