Home United States Georgia I Love NY Pizza

I Love NY Pizza

980 Birmingham Rd, Alpharetta, GA 30004, USA

Map

Detailed Information

Place Types Meal delivery
Address 980 Birmingham Rd, Alpharetta, GA 30004, USA
Coordinate 34.167392,-84.331983
Website http://www.ilovenypmilton.com/
Rating 4.4
Compound Code 5M89+X6 Alpharetta, GA, USA

Openning hours

Monday 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Tuesday 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Wednesday 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Thursday 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Friday 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Saturday 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Sunday 10:00 AM – 9:00 PM

Photos

Reviews

Tom Turney (01/24/2021)

I’m a repeat customer. Ordered a 2 topping pizza for delivery. The pizza delivered only had 1 of the toppings for $25 I would expect them to make it right I called and heard the girl on the phone arguing with the pizza maker that he swore it had both toppings. Well...it didn’t. They came back on the phone and said they would delivery me a replacement. They never showed. After another hour of waiting we called at about 8:45. They didn’t answer. Pizza box says they’re open until 10:00 and Google says they’re open until 9:30. Decided to drive down there and arrived at 9:11 on a Saturday night. They were closed. Lights out. Needless to say, they’ve lost a customer and I would not recommend ordering from them. Pizza is good. Service recovery is non existent.

Olivia (02/28/2021)

Worst service ever. Called to make a Togo order and didn’t check my food until I got home. The pizza I ordered was wrong and called the store to get a new one, all was fine until I got a call back and someone at the store proceeded to tell me that I was wrong and they did not mess up my food. Looking at my wrong pizza infront of me I proceeded to tell them that they messed up but the man on the phone told me I was wrong. The customer is never wrong and they could not admit that they messed up my order. So incredibly ridiculous and I will never ever order from this location again. Shame on y’all.

Chris A (01/26/2021)

Omg amazing pizza! Finally found my go to pizza place, cooked perfectly and crust was amazing. They must be shipping water in from NY to make this cause it's spot on!

Harry Joiner (03/24/2021)

A rare gem of a place. Old school awesomeness, right down the road. ud83dudd25ud83cudf55ud83dudd25

lman B (03/27/2021)

Possibly the worst delivery service I've ever seen. We've order from this place multiple times through their delivery service (SliceLife) & almost 80% of the time us nor the delivery service can reach them. Almost every single time we've ordered from here they usually just don't make the food & close down. They've never answered the phone when we have this problem & instead we calling up the delivery service & they themselves don't have a clue what happened. Even tonight we tried ordering way before closing hours & they didn't even cancel the order, just closed down without a word.

Similar place

Domino's Pizza

2400 12th St NW Bldg C, Albuquerque, NM 87104, USA

35.1096655, -106.6572365

+1 505-345-9936

https://www.dominos.com/en/?utm_source=google&utm_medium=loclis

Pizza Hut

700 Lomas Blvd NW, Albuquerque, NM 87102, USA

35.0911907, -106.6543548

+1 505-242-9400

https://locations.pizzahut.com/nm/albuquerque/700-lomas-blvd-nw

Jimmy John's