Tonys Italians Pizziera and Restaurant

This is an above-the-extraordinary place to eat. The food is phenomenal and the prices are not unreasonable. Specials on Wednesday and Thursday are the way to go. I myself prefer lasagna or the spaghetti and meatball dishes but I have tried most things and everything I have tasted is wonderful. The staff and waitresses are courteous and friendly and most times more than helpful. This is a place where you should go if you want to spend a little time eating dinner and don’t mind waiting for excellent food. I give them five stars and would give them more if I could. The perfect place to dine in Farmingdale.

Great people, servers, and service. The pizza has very good crust and the sauce isn't sweet, with a good selection of toppings. A very popular stop in the area for locals and visitors alike!!

Probably wouldn't have survived without them at least a few times since Covid and especially with all this snow recently.nOur household most definitely orders Tony's more than seems normal or healthy but it's not stopping us.nLocal businesses deserve our patronage to keep their doors from closing in our town.. Thank you Tony's staff for being normalcy in the most abnormal of times and weather.

Nice place but how can you get everything I order wrong?? First time we ordered a regular pizza pie with tomatoes...They delivered, opened the box & it was a White Pie with tomatoes...no sauce at all....Second time I ordered a Chicken Caesar Sub...got to my destination & it was a Buffalo Chicken Sub...so spicy hot I couldn't eat it... Yesterday was the last an final time ordering from here....I ordered a Turkey Sub with Lettuce, Tomatoes & oil & vinegar...Got to my destination & there was no oil & vinegar at all...So dry to eat... Terrible...Lost me as a customer...Wish the employees answering the phone & the ones making the food would get it right!!

Best square pie tonight. Extra cheese half sausage a little crisp.