Casey's

We've had pizza from about every pizza place in Greencastle but Casey's still wins hands down! They're sauce is perfect and just the right amount. The original crust is perfect, just thick enough and never burnt! The cheese is creamy and generous. The spicy sausage is a fantastic addition to any pizza! YUM! And the veggies are always nice and fresh! And don't get me started on their cookies and doughnuts! Sooooo GOOD!nnAND equally important is the staff...these folks are super nice! On our last order the lady figured out a way to save me $5 on the pizza we ordered just by changing the base part of the order!!! So we got delicious, hot, fresh pizza and a surprise savings of $5! They are ALWAYS nice!nnAND SO VERY CLEAN CLEAN CLEAN! You can see the entire prep area! We love you Casey's Greencastle!

Always has a long line, it's need faster service.

It wasn't busy. Got in and out quick.

I never expected gas station pizza to be good but is actually pretty awesome. Flat bread breakfast pizza

This location is updated and has been consistently clean. Staff is friendly. Convenient location right on highway.