Papa Gelateria

Excellent authentic gelato and pastries, this place is a gem hidden in the historic district of New Castle. The owner is always friendly and seems to truly love his business. We wait patiently for them to announce all their new goodies!

I ended up stopping in for some gelato after popping by the highschool for pictures. I then proceeded to try everything in their menu, and am glad to say, I enjoyed everything I tasted. I stayed there for 4 hours and didn't want to leave. The owner is a very relaxed and friendly young man and I enjoyed chatting with him. Wish I could live there, hands down one of the best experiences in this town.

Just stopped in after a day of hiking with the family. We opted to get the $20 sample platter. Loved every flavor, we will certainly stop back again soon

The staff was friendly. The flavor was rich. I want to return to try their coffee!

Great staff and amazing ice cream. Also they have the best coffee around.