AJ's Pizza Butler

Family owned and run. You will not be disappointed by Aj's pizza. They put their heart and soul into the business. Take the time to make sure every meal is done with excellence

We are on a mission to find the best Margarita, Grandma, & Grandpa Pizza in North Jersey! We gave AJ's Pizza, Butler, NJ a try.nWe ordered the Margarita pie, pepperoni pie, and a Grandma. Up first the Margarita pie: the dough was okay - a little dry/overcooked. The fresh mozzarella was placed on the pie perfectly, revealing the sauce. The sauce was very similar to the sauce used on the traditional pie. The basil did not have too much taste mostly due to it being baked onto the pie. Overall this was not a bad margarita pie especially for the price. What we really enjoyed with AJ's is their online ordering, prices, and coupons that can be added directly to the online cart! SO far this has been the easiest and best ordering experience for us. A job well done, AJ 's on this!

We are on a mission to find the best Margarita, Grandma, & Grandpa Pizza in North Jersey! We gave AJ's Pizza, Butler, NJ a try.nWe ordered the Margarita pie, pepperoni pie, and a Grandma. Up first the Margarita pie: the dough was okay - a little dry/overcooked. The fresh mozzarella was placed on the pie perfectly, revealing the sauce. The sauce was very similar to the sauce used on the traditional pie. The basil did not have too much taste mostly due to it being baked onto the pie. Overall this was not a bad margarita pie especially for the price. What we really enjoyed with AJ's is their online ordering, prices, and coupons that can be added directly to the online cart! SO far this has been the easiest and best ordering experience for us. A job well done, AJ 's on this!nnThe Grandma. No difference with the Margarita. Basically, they took the margarita and threw it on a square pizza. The dough was the same as the Margarita. We were missing the fresh garlic and sweeter sauce for this.nnNote: AJ's did not have a Grandpa (or upside down sicilian) on the menu so we couldn't give that a try. Instead we ordered a small pepperoni. The dough was fresher than the other two pies, cheese cooked perfectly, and not too greasy. This was definitely the best of the three.nnOnto the next pizzeria, we are trying one every Friday night. What else is there to do during this pandemic? Any suggestions on what pizzeria we should try next... let us know!!!

I would definitely recommend AJ's Pizza. but lately it seems to be hit or miss. I always loved the meat lovers stromboli or meat lovers calzone. but the last two times I ordered them they were small and just did not have the same flavor. I ordered a Italian sub and that also was lacking in the meat department hardly any oil or vinegar. I did however order tortellini alfredo and that was delicious. I have been going to AJ's since the day they open. and never have been disappointed. until now I hope it's only because they are opened another store and things with covid-19 been difficult.

Absolutely horrible experience!!! I have worked in and managed many restaurants and I have to say this is one of the worst experiences I've ever had with any restaurant! I ordered my food on line I was given a 90 minute web order time.