Gatto's Pizza

Definitely would not come back here. Crust is bland, ingredients taste cheap. Sausage tastes a little like meatloaf. Hardly any cheese when I asked for extra. Garlic bread was pretty pathetic.

Always excellent food no matter what you order. Always puts the customer FIRST. I've been going there for over 20 years. Drove from Pickerington to pick it up.

Walked in to pick up my pizza that took 30 minutes to make and the first thing I see is some guy with fingernail polish slicing bell pepper with his bare hands, 5 other workwrs running around behind the counter clueless. Instead of cashing me out the clerk decides to take another order and let my pizza continue to get cold. But the worst part...I ordered extra cheese, and the edges of my pizza not only had no cheese but no toppings. Upon tasting my pizza it now tastes like someones hamds and cologne! This is by far the worst pizza I have ever gotten and will not be eating here ever again!

Had it delivered. From a place a good half hour from where we live. OMG. Delicious. Whomever is cooking the subs, kudos. Perfect. I got it with the dressing on the side. Italian. You don't need no dressing. So good. Crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. The meat has its own flavor. Fabulous. The pizza. Wow. Got a supreme. Awesome. I would give it 10 stars if I could.

Best cheesy garlic bread in town!