Talayna's Wagon Wheel Pizza

The food and service is fantastic. I have been coming here for years and hope to be coming for many more. While service may seem a little slow at times, it is definitely worth the wait. I have tried almost the entire menu and have never been disappointed. I would highly recommend eating here.

I ordered a Large NY pizza with pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, and jalapeños with two slices only having pepperoni. I ordered at 5:57 and was told 25-30 min. I arrived on time went in nobody came to see if anyone else came in, I waited over 8 minutes before anybody came from back area. Did not acknowledge me they went straight to customers there not once but twice and I finally got acknowledged. I said I placed a to go order waitress said just a minute. In the mean time other customers came in and she walked right passed me again not telling me anything. After 10 minutes another waitress came out with a order for somebody else on a pick up. I asked the 1st waitress again about my order I told her I called it in at 557, I did not get my pizza until 651. I get home pizza is soggy and warm. For $35. the pizza was not worth it. I will not return period. Poor customer service + wait time + quality of food = bad review. They were not that busy to where I could have received better service and quality of food. Will not return.

I had the toasted ravioli and a St. Louis style pizza with sausage and pepperoni. The ravioli was very disappointing and not any better than store bought frozen, but the marinara was exceptionally good. The pizza was above average, but comparing it to other St. Louis style pizza it fell a bit short. Final rankings: T-Ravioli (2 out of 10 stars). Marinara sauce (10 of 10 stars). Pizza (7 of 10 stars).

My pizza and salad was delicious. Service was excellent. Although it states you need reservations they were very accommodating

Great service. They even offered to bring my order out to our car. Best New York pizza anywhere.