Faye's Pizza

Recently ordered several chef salads. In the past the salads ud83eudd57 were awesome withe lage chunks of ham and a mound of delicious cheese ud83euddc0. Not a fan of the changes they made to it. Super thin ham and hardly any cheese. The also put some kind of seasoning on it that wasn't necessary.

We asked some friends for their pizza recommendation in the area and their unanimous recommendation was for Faye's -- and they were spot on! Servers were friendly and knowledgeable and the food was amazing. You owe it to yourself to try the sausage, which is made fresh at Miesfeld's.

The Faye's house deluxe pizza was really really good but there BLT pizza just didn't seem to be as good as last time I got it, but still good.

I am a chef, my friend who went with me is a cook with 14 years experience. Do you think we know food?nnA experience I will never forget.nnMy friend ordered a pizza, the pizza was fine, tasted as it should just like any other pizza place, not bad and nothing great. I tried a piece and my friend enjoyed it.nnI ordered the (cup of) chili, I thought it was bland. So I had my friend sample it, he said it was bland. So, I added hot chili flakes to elevate the flavor of the chili, no didnt help. Didnt want to finish it.nnMy entree arrives, it was the spaghetti. Ive been wanting some good spaghetti, craving it! It was bland...Again, to make sure my taste buds were working properly, I had my friend sample the spaghetti. And he said, yes its very bland...and he returns to finish his pizza. So, now I have a full cup of chili soup and an entire entree of spaghetti sitting in front of me. The nice little waitress, who did a great job, asked how my food was as she noticed, ive eaten nothing. Because I am a chef, I had to be honest. I told her, the spaghetti was bland and it had no taste at all, including the chili. She offered to box it all up for me and I told her no, I dont want any of it.nnAs we went to pay, I notice my bill. I had to pay full price for eating, nothing. I asked to talk to the owner and he quickly appeared. I told him the food was super bland ( an understatement ) and I ate nothing. He said, theres nothing he can do about the bill (literally) and he offered me, the SAUCE....which was the exact problem, the sauce was bland. But he wanted me to take some home HAHAHA...LOL. Not sure why he was trying to force me to take the sauce home. So, I said, if you want to make me pay full price for things I didnt eat, then I want my food and Ill take it home. This is approximately 10 mins into the confrontation. My food, APPEARS.....why did they save my food? when I told them, I didnt want to take it home because it was awfully bland. What were they saving my food for? as a cook, in any restaurant, if food comes back, its immediately disposed of!!! these people saved my food, after I told them I didnt want it!! WTH is going on??? my only guess is, to give to a different customer.......nnSo, after some more explaining to the owner that I didnt eat it because it was so bland and why didnt he throw away my food...he finally gives in and offers my a full discount. My friend paid for his pizza, nothing wrong there.nnSo...if your into flavorless food...and a restaurant that keeps food that is brought back....go there....as for people who enjoys flavor, we will go somewhere else....who saves food that was meant to be tossed out?? WOW...and who forces the sauce onto the one who doesnt like it? double wow! weirdo!!!!.....I laugh when I drive by, every time. (Im not from Sheyboygan)..who saves food that came back??? who?? LOL...wow

Best pizza you will find in Sheboygan County and quite frankly anywhere else. I took real Wisconsin cheese for granted until I moved to Florida 13 years ago. Faye's has the best ingredients and their thin crust is unrivaled. They are consistently voted the best pizza in Sheboygan for a reason.