Mystic Island Pizza

best pizza in town dislike all the others wont eat at any other its this place or domino cause domino 2nd best in town to me

Pizza couldve been a bit better but it was still very good food

Great food! I love it! Great value! Have seen seen their subs?! Delicious! Nice folks!nn(I have to sneak though, as my son's future in-laws, who are very much loved and respected by me, own a local competitive restaurant.)

The food has gotten so much better. They are fast, good and not extremely expensive.

Hands down this is the most consistent pizzeria from Barnegat all the way down to Galloway! I’m a Jersey City/Bayonne guy so I’m very picky on my Italian restaurants! So for starters they have the most absolute fantastic mussels I’ve ever eaten, even better than up top! Also the marinara forget about it, it’s unreal! I’ve been down here for almost a year and I let this place slip by under the radar. What a mistake! You want some tasty food this is the spot! Chicken parm is phenomenal, chicken cutlet sandwich is delicious, the cheesesteaks are slamming! This joint is the TRUTH!!