Cape May Peanut Butter Co.

Just finished my butterscotch peanut butter and wish I had more. So, so good. If you love peanut butter this is the place to go. They have a variety of flavors - chocolate, butterscotch, plain and everything in between. Additionally, they have yummy baked goods and other fun stuff to buy. The shop is small, but cute and fun to browse. Always visit when we go to Cape May

Gotta go if you are a peanut butter fan!

I had the sweetest time visiting this place! I was blown away by the customer service - the woman who was working when I was there yesterday on Sunday went above and beyond to show me and other customers what the Peanut Butter Company is all about, and clearly cares about what she does. I had a delicious sandwich with honey roasted peanut butter, bananas, and bacon - absolutely delicious and comforting. Their peanut butter has an incredible taste and texture unlike the typical store-bought type. Loved what I got and can’t wait to return!

It took a few minutes to get in due to the Chinese Flu restrictions but well worth the wait. Had purchased some cappuccino peanut butter that is amazing. Had some coffee and a few peanut butter cookies. If you are in the area well worth the wait if you like peanut butter

best peanut butter in the state! great employees, too !