Keyport Fishery

This place is so good, don't know why I would go anywhere else to get fish now. Get it cooked or fresh, so delicious! Make sure you bring cash, cash only! But they have ATM'S there. Cooked food ends at 7 fresh fish ends at 8, definitely worth checking it out

Best fried seafood takeout in NJ! Also best New England clam chowder which can be brought home cold or hot sold in pints or quarts. With covid one must call in order from parking lot and wait for call back when ready. One goes to pickup window to pickup. Also they sell fresh uncooked seafood of many varieties. Place has been in business for many years with change of ownership.

The best fish around! Never ever disappointed. I am impatient and find no problem waiting in line. This place is packed every time but they have it moving like a well oiled machine. #freshndelish

DONT WASTE YOUR MONEY!! So disappointing! After hearing how great it USED to be we ate there. Very expensive for portion size and quality. Fish had no flavor, Lobster sandwich was a tiny piece of Lobster slapped on a McDonald’s hamburger bun, only shriveled up and smaller! Flounder sandwich slapped on thin white bread on a plate thrown in a bag!! Fries were dry, no salt. They charge for ketchup and salt, cash only so very inconvenient. $65 for lunch for 4. Better off eating at Jersey Mike’s. Very rude customer service. Unorganized ordering and pickup process. People making food with no gloves on while touching their faces! Extremely disappointed!! Please don’t waste your money!! If I could give them a minus 5 that would be too much!! Unbelievable how they stay in business!!

47 and I've been eating here my entire life...my grampa used to bring me when I was a child. I will continue to eat here as long as I'm alive and they're open. Keyport Fishery serves truly old fashioned seafood quickly and more importantly...consistently. I can see why some folks might think service is rude...but, as a completely unbiased party...all they are is busy. They might be gruff, but, not rude at all...they have to keep things moving because they are *always* busy. Always. That's a good sign you want to eat there.