Goldberg's Famous Bagels

Very disappointed. The lady who helped us was rude and seemed annoyed by our easy order. We ordered buttons (which they were out of) 4 bagels (not cut, nothing on them) a pound of vegetable cream cheese (which they had to make because they only had about a quarter left) and a roll, that’s relatively easy especially since she was writing it down. Upon arriving home, they missed part of our order. They were out of things we ordered and had only been open for 2 hours. You would think on a Sunday morning they would have things extra prepared and ready to go. As a first time customer I can tell you I will not go back.

Great sandwiches. Always a little wait even if you call and order ahead of time. Present situation there is no order. People waiting an hr for food. Phone orders to go not ready for 25-30 min after arrival. Probably overwhelmed from shop in Pompton Lakes being sold.

There's a reason the place is usually busy. Everything they make is great

Freshest bagels in the area. Pretty girls to look at while you wait.

I called to place an order at 10:36 this Saturday.nI think I recognized the voice taking the order as the owner Rob. As I placed my order, exactly as I have ordered in the store for years, “egg sandwich, double egg, double cheese with pepper jack cheese and bacon,” he was so intent on interrupting me to tell me what his sandwiches had on them already, he didn’t listen to my detail of requesting pepperjack cheese.nI was told 20 minutes.nMy daughter arrived at 20 minutes and had to wait with those that had not called in an order for her chance to pick up our order, another 10+ minutes.nNot a great experience. She arrived home and my sandwich was exactly “as he makes them” with America cheese instead of the pepperjack I had asked for.nI have read complaints over the years about incorrect orders, which can happen, but this was the owner who showed he is careless. I have bitten my tongue, continued to support and talked up Goldbergs because of the hard working counter people such as Kate, Heather and others doing their best. I have quietly returned from home to give them a chance to correct my order, which they gladly do.nRob ruined my breakfast sandwich. I didn’t return to get a correct sandwich since it would mean waiting in line or imposing on those already in line and then waiting for the correct sandwich.nI don’t plan on going there ever again. I’ve seen or heard others say that and didn’t anticipate I would feel this way but I do. I am done.nCupsaw Market cares!