Lyndhurst Pastry Shop

Had a wonderful experience ordering a dozen cupcakes over the phone, on short notice, as a gift for my coworker’s wedding this weekend. Haley was very professional, friendly, and helpful over the phone. The cupcakes were delivered in perfect condition, complete with a hand-written note that I had dictated over the phone, to my coworker. She sent a photo and the cupcakes look delicious. If I didn’t live in Manhattan with no car, I would be over there in a second to try out everything they sell. Thanks, Lyndhurst Pastry Shop! Will definitely recommend you to friends and coworkers.

I go there for the Italian ice and fresh bread, although the pastries I've tried have all been good as well. The bread tastes like something your Italian grandma would bring fresh out of the oven - crispy on the outside, yet buttery soft on the inside. It's my favorite. My go-to place for cookies by the pound as well.

I LOVE this bakery!! It's owned by some of the nicest people you'll ever meet...you can tell that they really love their business. Their Italian ice is out of this world as is the cannoli cake. I love popping in whenever I pass by for a few treats!

Great pastries!!!!

Excellent lemon ice