Mrs Pumpkin's Bakery-Deli

We love Mrs. Pumpkin's chicken pies! This quaint store is easy to miss along busy Reynolda Rd. See the pics but it basically sits in a tiny strip mall directly beside and slightly behind the Sherwin Williams store. They have great desserts too but I didn't purchase any today.

Ordered a birthday cake for Christmas Day. I was afraid they'd couldn't accommodate us being a busy holiday. They were pleasant when taking my order and even helped me decide on the cake decoration. I ordered a strawberry cake with cream cheese frosting and it was fantastic. Very moist and flavorful. I was afraid the icing would be dry or have that latex-y taste to it but it wasn't. It was so good. We ended up buying other items to give as gifts. Will definitely keep going here.

Had been buying Moravion Love Feast Buns from another bakery in town for years, but for the last few years they tasted like they had been frozen after baking and thawed out the day they were placed out on display for sale. A friend recommended Mrs Pumpkins bakery to us. Went to the store and bought a dozen of their buns, it was unreal how much the difference was in the taste and freshness over the other bakery. Wish I had bought a couple more dozen of them but if I had I would not have an excuse to go back for more and try some of their family size frozen entrees. If you want fresh baked Love Feast Buns this is the only place I have found to get them.

Perfect place for ready to cook family meals and sides. The cream cheese brownies are delightful!

Mrs. Pumpkin's Fundraiser event is WONDERFUL. We just finished up our 11th annual Chicken Pie Fundraiser and what a fun, easy way to raiser funds for our ladies church group. Mrs. Pumpkin's does all the work and all we had to do was sell their wonderful Chicken Pies. I would strongly suggest utilizing this great source for fundraising.