Baked from the Hart

My husband and I tried the sweet bean & pecan pies, along with the blackberry cobbler. I loved all of the pies, and the sweet bean was my favorite- like a cross between a sweet potato and pumpkin pie, with a nice smooth texture. The cobbler was amazing, not too sweet with a good crust-to-filling ratio. The owner, Bill, recommended that I warm it up and I’m glad I did! The pecan pie reminded me of back home in South Carolina- sweet, sticky, and a tiny hint of smokiness from the toasted pecans. The best part of my experience was chatting with Bill and learning more about him and his business. Will be back soon, highly recommend- Be sure to grab a paper on your way out!

Stopped by on a whim while driving through Columbia City. Owner was very nice. Pies were delicious! We tried the medium Apple and medium Peach cobblers. I would recommend this place to anyone visiting south Seattle :)

By far the best pies I have had out of Seattle. The space is very pleasant, and I am looking forward to enjoying it post-COVID. The prices are a little high, but I feel you will not be disappointed with the flavor and quality of the pie. The chess pie had a beautiful consistency and buttermilk flavor, and the pecan pie had a amazing and silky filling. I can't way to try more of the options.

These pies are amazing! The variety of pies and the story behind the business is really inspiring. There is a nice little place to sit and enjoy a coffee and indulge your sweet tooth. Or just order them to go. There are small, medium, and large sizes of the pies. The tarts are great bite size party favors. The mediums are great for a slice for yourself and the large is perfect for sharing with others. Support the Pie Guy!

Excellent selections from a true craftsman. Miniature pastry with world class flavors. We tried peach cobbler and chocolate cake with real whipped cream topping and filling. Can't wait to go back and try something else. The proprietor was charming.