DeWitt Bagel Company

My boyfriend and I came in on a weekend maybe 5 or 10 minutes after opening, we were en route somewhere very early and wanting bagels. We had never been here before and it was exciting to find a place nearby that wasn’t a chain. There were two customers in front of us who were being treated very nicely with great customer service. For some reason that warmth changed when it was our turn to order and it felt like us being there was an inconvenience. The two employees seemed annoyed? My boyfriend got the Jersey Boy and absolutely loved it- Taylor ham/pork rolls are rare up here. I got an egg and cheese on a bagel and really enjoyed it, I wish I had known to order it with two eggs because it was on the thin side but nevertheless still really tasty! I wish I could give this 4 or 5 stars because we did really like the food but were very turned off by the service we got. Maybe we’ll try coming later than 7.

I’m so surprised at all these 5 star reviews. I really wanted to like this place. (Remember the old Dewitt Bagels? Yum!) Unfortunately the half dozen bagels I took home were really bland and bread-like. I couldn’t even cut through them without them completely collapsing, but they weren’t still warm. I guess maybe if I’d ordered a sandwich like most of the other reviewers the quality of the bagel may have been less important. Really disappointing. Two stars for nice staff, though.

They have really good bagels at reasonable prices. We got two sandwiches on our first visit. The Ol’ Faithful and Buffalo, both were great! I would definitely recommend this establishment if you’re in the mood for a bagel.

I’m gluten free & dairy free and my breakfast sandwich tasted amazing this morning ! The staff was super quick and made my custom order efficiently ! The manager was informative and kind. Support this local business every morning that you’re in a crunch for time and need a WHOLESOME breakfast on the go !

I love this place! Best bagels/cream cheese/breakfast sandwiches in the area. I hope to try their regular sandwiches soon.