Stonecutters Tavern at Belhurst Castle

This is a great casual American restaurant with delicious food and wonderful customer service. They even offer gluten free buns!! The food was really yummy and the staff was super attentive.

Pretty tasty French onion soup with lots of cheese on top,, but could have been hotter. Beef vegetable soup was overloaded with black pepper. Reuben sandwich was excellent - best I've had in a long time. Shrimp sandwich was good too. Large portions for both sandwiches. Beautiful location with Seneca Lake vista. Historic building. We'll be back again sometime.

Loved it here! We sat at the bar which gives a great view of the lake. Drinks and food were both delicious.

My boyfriend and I ordered the white knight sangria and lake water lemonade drinks. They were extremely sweet and we could barely drink them. Did not taste alcoholic at all, just syrupy and sugary. My boyfriend ordered the French onion steak and I ordered the shrimp sandwich. Sandwich barely came with any fries at all, probably 12 total. Food was very subpar and for the price absolutely not worth it. The view is pretty and the ambiance is nice at the restaurant, but the service and food were not worth it. The server did not check on us and did not even bring water. Food took an hour to come out. Expected much better.

We came here at the beginning of September, 2020. The service is pretty good, we had no issues during our visit. The food and atmosphere are lackluster. The tables inside are the type you’d expect to see at an eating area in a grocery store, and the food is at the same level. I had the burger with fries. I ordered it medium, and it was well done. There were HUGE slices of onion on the burger and a lot of mayo. The fries were clearly just frozen waffle cut, nothing special. I wouldn’t recommend this place, but maybe the actual dining room is better!