Pizza Pantry

The pizza & wings here have gone down hill. I agree with a lot of reviews from previous years but as far as the pass year this place has no pride in what they serve anymore. You would think that celebrating 35 years the food would be of top quality.

Their food is pretty good

I agree with other reviews, the pizza was horrible. Really bad. My 5 year old even refused to eat it. The jalapeno hamburger was good. The staff was awesome and super nice!

Surprisingly good pizza in a rural venue. The owner is a gem. I had tree sap from elsewhere on my windshield. I asked if he had a rag I could use to try to get it off and he produced glass cleaner and then helped me to scrub my windshield. The Pizza Pantry is a good place for smaller groups to use for receptions. The menu for ours was excellent.

Pizza and wings are great! We ended up ordering twice over two days. Convenient for ordering from Darien Lake. We will be back next visit!