Andy’s Restaurant Greenport New York

My boyfriend and I found ourselves in the area during the off season and went here because everywhere else was closed. Honestly disappointed. The clam chowder was ok, but definitely not the best. Bit overpriced too. Also the calamari we ordered was really bland. The sauce that came with it was pretty bad too, really watery. All in all, it wasn’t terrible but definitely not as good as it cost. Service wasn’t great either. Waitress didn’t seem to pay much attention to us, as she messed up one of our orders. Won’t be coming back here.

Great food. Relaxed atmosphere. Great service.

They seem at first like a place that would serve just average bar food but when you actually get there and get your food its presentation is incredible on top of that the food is some of the best ive tasted

I've been here a few times now, and I've always enjoyed the experience. The staff is friendly, the food is good, and there's always been a pleasant atmosphere there.

I wasn't sure what to expect because it was not our first choice. All the classic places in Greenport were full and had a long wait. The menu looked okay. You were greeted when we walked in. They offered us a place inside or in their back patio. The wait staff was courteous and professional. The food was unbelievable. Fresh full of flavor. My wife got the octopus salad and the octopus was cooked perfectly. Octopuses usually something that is overcooked but not here. It may not have Waterfront views but don't overlook this place